Prof. ST Hsieh
Director, US-China Energy Industry Forum
626-376-7460
December 2, 2023
Morality is a universal virtue that should be upheld by individuals as well as governments. However, the world is not perfect and not uniform. Of course, any foreign assassination plot against any national should be vehemently protested and the criminal should be prosecuted by local laws. Murder is murder!
But the reality is that international order respects national boundary. The long arm of law enforcement has its limits. In this case of US Manhattan district attorney vs Government of India in Deli, not only the geographical distance makes it very difficult but also the difference of political cultures must be considered. For India, Sikh separatists are a critical threat to India as a nation. Human rights are not the issue at all, foreign interferences are non-sense.
It is the same case as the US went after the terrorists all over the world related to 911 attack. For the US, it is absolutely within her rights of the US that we went after any US perceived suspect anywhere in the world was justified. The point is that it is not worthy the risk of breaking up global partnership just for human right issues or morality. After all no one is perfect, criminal should be persecuted by loal law where the crime was committed. But for the federal government to engage foreign capital would not be productive.
Editorial: All over the map: India assassination plot against US citizen breaches international order
New York Daily News Editorial Board, New York Daily News
Fri, December 1, 2023 at 1:00 AM PST·
In a federal indictment this week, Manhattan U.S. Attorney Damian Williams unveiled an indictment against Nikhil Gupta, an alleged Indian narcotics trafficker who prosecutors say had attempted to hire a hitman— who turned out to be an undercover federal agent — to assassinate Sikh separatist leader Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, a U.S. citizen. The feds say Gupta, who was arrested in the Czech Republic, was directed by a senior Indian government official.
The details sound like something out of a spy novel, but in the real world there are no suave super-spies in tailored suits always ready to save the day.
Just a couple of months ago, Sikh activist Hardeep Singh Nijjar was assassinated in British Columbia, after which Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced that the Canadian government was investigating potential ties between the killing and the government of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. That accusation and the subsequent diplomatic turmoil shocked the world, but now twice is a pattern.
In this case, while the specific Indian official who is alleged to have ordered the assassination is not identified, the U.S. intelligence services apparently have direct communications between Mr. X and Gupta, including the directive that Pannun’s murder was “a priority now.” Gupta also allegedly told the undercover that Nijjar’s murder was part of the same operation and that “we have so many targets.” The international community should ensure that Nijjar is the last.
The long tendrils of right-wing authoritarianism are spreading across the world, far outside the borders of the strongmen themselves. It’s certainly not the first time in modern history that despots have directed killings and abductions well beyond their putative jurisdictions, but the brazenness is only getting worse, an indication of the extent to which these figures feel unconstrained by international consequences.
Not that dictators killing their opposition domestically is acceptable; the general project of political violence and demonization that seems to be progressing around the globe, including in the United States, portends dark days ahead. Still, it is especially galling for these antidemocratic factions to reach around the globe to the places where democracy is holding on and assert their authoritarian power.
These operations don’t just target one person or group, they target the whole of the liberal project and the the very principles of freedom of expression and political organization, sending the message that no matter where you are, you should be looking over your shoulder if you have too stringently criticized a certain regime.
The only way this stops is if it becomes clear to those regimes that they also won’t be safe from the blowback. The Biden administration is right to have impressed on India that this would not be tolerated, dispatching the CIA director to deliver the message.
Hopefully, the president will make this a consistent policy, and outline heavy consequences for all governments that would cross this line, including our pals the Saudis. The commitments we make will always ring hollow if we forget about travesties like the killing of Jamal Khashoggi.