Prof. ST Hsieh
Director, US-China Energy Industry Forum
December 21, 2022
The following analysis is for investment opportunities in the US LNG industry. The US LNG export capacity is already top of the world and keeps expanding. Obviously, investors in the global LNG industry do feel confident and the future is bright. Natural gas has been formally adapted as the clean transition fuel for reaching the carbon neutral world.
The war in Ukraine, however, has given the US LNG industry a unique advantage in the European markets. Politicians in Europe are responsible for the dire energy shortages now. The geopolitical reason for this war in Ukraine is the European politicians decided to cut off the “over dependence” of Russian energy without a reasonable back out plan to replace Russian gas supply. The author pointed out the obvious: Short-term solutions seem to be Europe’s only interest. But most likely, these inept politicians also do not have any collective wisdom to speak of.
Now, they have to take the gamble of price cap on Russian oil and gas, to appease their constituents so they can hold on to their jobs. The immediate danger of price caps is also obvious that it is very difficult to implement in any globally traded commodity. The price of any globally traded community is, by and large, determined by supply and demand and it is often volatile. So, setting a static price cap on one of the major suppliers is challenging to begin with. But the price cap is also a difficult compromise among European nations.
But fundamentally, price cap is against market economy or global trade. The announcement of price cap on oil and gas by a large trading block such as Europe is damaging to the credibility of global energy trading system. Enforcing such a price cap in the global market is forcing the global energy trading system into unchartered water. The only outcome can be expected is market chaos, more expensive oil and gas, and less liquidity.
Our best hope is that this price cap scheme collapses as soon as possible.
Europe’s Price Cap Is a Dangerous Gamble
LUKE SWEENEY | DEC 21, 2022
The EU may have enough juice to keep its own members in line, but it is powerless against the will of U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG) producers.
Europe currently has its stockpiles full to the brim with either Russian leftovers or regasified U.S. LNG. Those are its two options for the next few years.
Unless EU leaders are concocting some last-ditch effort to force Putin into a change of heart, I’d say the U.S. is Europe’s best chance at keeping energy flowing into 2023 and beyond.
My heart goes out to the citizens being gouged thanks to a conflict they had no part in starting. But U.S. LNG producers are unlikely to feel the same way.
The EU is currently voting on a price cap for natural gas. It would limit the cost to €180 ($191) per megawatt hour if prices continue to soar out of control.
From a citizen’s perspective, that’s fantastic news. Some countries in the bloc were paying upward of five times their usual bulk rate.
But for the producers who are obligated only to the almighty dollar, that price cap is to be avoided like the plague.
Stealing From Tomorrow to Pay for Today
I’m sure many of them thought that nine months ago, back when this supposed “special military action” was expected to end in just weeks.
The truth is Russian gas supplies stand a very real chance of never returning to Europe. If Putin continues to control the country, I don’t expect him to forgive and forget so soon.
U.S. LNG is the only short-term option that makes sense. Anything else won’t be ready for years at minimum.
And since Russia is still dishing out oil and gas at exorbitant prices to Asian countries, the market for U.S. LNG is worldwide.
If Europe decides it doesn’t want to pay the market rate for LNG, producers will simply take their incredibly flexible fleets of LNG delivery vehicles and sail them to a better port.
Again, I can’t argue with the decision that much. The EU is just trying to protect consumers from the insane price surges caused by Russia departing.
But considering those leaders might be the exact same ones who got their countries hooked on Russian gas in the first place, I don’t feel sorry for them.
And if they think prices are bad now, wait until they scare away U.S. deliveries by trying to sloppily fix their nations’ own mistakes.
Setting a price ceiling like this without implementing any hard-core demand-control measures is just asking for trouble.
It’s a recipe for nationwide blackouts. Not only will the U.S. be taking its services elsewhere, but no European country will have the bargaining power to secure outside supply. All competitors would need to do is beat out €180.
That shouldn’t be too tough when half the planet is hard up for energy.
At the risk of sounding insensitive, this is an unbelievable profit opportunity disguised as a crisis.
Competition over U.S. LNG has sent prices to absurd heights. Europe managed to beat most of its competitors, but that won’t last long.
Soon, buyers from all over the world will be digging deep to get their own deliveries. Europe will either be forced to backtrack its decision or get left behind.
For the U.S. companies that are expanding like mad, that’s the best possible news.
Production capacity in the U.S. is set to expand from 11.1 billion cubic feet per day (Bcf/d) to 20 Bcf/d by the end of 2025.
That means even if Europe abandons its price cap, the U.S. will still have more than enough to spread around.
It’s a bull run with a practically guaranteed five-year runway. I can’t imagine a better sign to invest in U.S LNG.
Our team has been following this market for years now — decades, even. We’ve seen moments like this before, and we know exactly where the biggest profit opportunities lie.
To your wealth,
Contributor, Energy and Capital